Reviewer:   Jim "JR" Rutkowski
Directed by:
Anthony Russo, Joe Russo
Written by:
Screenplay by Christopher Markus & Stephen McFeely. Based on the Marvel story by Mark Millar.
Chris Evans, Robert Downey Jr., Scarlett Johansson
Length:   113 minutes
Released:   050616
Rated PG-13 for extended sequences of violence, action and mayhem
“This is the best “Captain America” film to date and the best “Avengers” film to date."

Most of the old gang (sans Thor and Bruce Banner) and a few new faces are present and accounted for in "Captain America: Civil War," the fully realized, character-centric crowd-pleaser 2015's lackluster, convoluted "The Avengers: Age of Ultron" never quite was. Returning to helm following 2014's superhero ode to '70s paranoid thrillers "Captain America: The Winter Soldier," Anthony Russo and Joe Russo pick back up without missing a beat, managing what Joss Whedon failed to achieve in "Ultron:" handily juggle an ever-expanding ensemble without losing sight of their established relationships and camaraderie. The Russos and screenwriters Christopher Markus and Stephen McFeely (2013's "Thor: The Dark World") also don't skimp on a quality storyline, one offering a politically and morally incisive debate (not unlike 2016's "Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice") on the culpability of planet-saving superheroes in the wake of unavoidable destruction and human sacrifice.

When a battle against bio-terrorists in Lagos ends in an accidental death toll at the telekinetic hands of Wanda Maximoff/Scarlet Witch (Elizabeth Olsen), the Avengers find themselves under increased scrutiny by the United Nations. The proposal of the Sokovia Accords—a legal document backed by 117 countries binding the Avengers to closer government supervision and great accountability for their actions—divides the team down the middle. Haunted by a chance run-in he has with the mother (Alfre Woodard) of an innocent victim who perished under his watch, Tony Stark/Iron Man (Robert Downey Jr.) is supportive of the legislation. While Natasha Romanoff/Black Widow (Scarlett Johansson), Lt. James Rhodes/War Machine (Don Cheadle), and philosophical humanoid Vision (Paul Bettany) join Tony in the pro column, Steve Rogers/Captain America (Chris Evans) is stridently against it, believing this increased control will ultimately hinder their duties. With Wanda, Sam Wilson/Falcon (Anthony Mackie), and newly unretired Clint Barton/Hawkeye (Jeremy Renner) backing Steve's cause, allegiances on both sides are formed as the threat of criminal penalties loom. Further complicating matters is a deadly bombing claiming the life of the peace-seeking leader of Wakanda, King T'Chaka (John Kani). Steve's former friend, the mind-controlled Bucky Barnes/Winter Soldier (Sebastian Stan), is suspected of the attack, but a sneakier foe in the form of string-pulling, vengeance-hungry Helmut Zemo (Daniel Brühl) waits methodically in the wings.

Many of the actors left stifled by the clumsy, unfocused writing in "Age of Ultron"—here's looking at Chris Evans's (2014's "Snowpiercer") freedom-fighting Steve Rogers, Scarlett Johansson's (2016's "Hail, Caesar!") smooth operator Natasha Romanoff, and most notably Robert Downey Jr.'s (2014's "Chef") droll, emotionally plagued Tony Stark—return to their glory as they meaningfully interact with each other and are given their own personal viewpoints. The film, delving deeper into Tony's past and the loss of parents Howard (John Slattery) and Maria (Hope Davis), could just as easily have been the fourth "Iron Man" installment without a frame of footage having to be changed. Moreover, an early flashback to Tony's young-adult self may be the most stunning special effect of all, with Downey Jr. de-aged to look exactly as he did in his late-teens/early-20s.

By taking the time to further develop their protagonists, directors Anthony Russo and Joe Russo allow the viewers to see them as people and not just super-powered icons. A scene between Wanda and Vision where he attempts to cook for the first time, for example, has little to do with the central plot but is the sort of special observational touch that we rarely see in a superhero film. The centerpiece set-piece everyone will be talking about—a mano-a-mano airport-set showdown between the squabbling heroes—is total fun in spite of its insignificance; for all their disagreements, they are still friends who wouldn't seriously harm each other. More provocatively enticing are the verbal debates igniting from both corners, the squad wanting to do what is best for the world while regaining the trust of citizens who have begun to perceive them as vigilantes rather than selfless good guys.

Also a rousing success are the key introductions of two new players who, in the coming years, will be receiving their own standalone features. Skepticism over a third actor in the span of nine years portraying a new incarnation of Peter Parker/Spider-Man (following Tobey Maguire and Andrew Garfield) vanishes in an instant as the immensely likable, youthful, genuine Tom Holland (2012's "The Impossible") walks onto the screen; he is fantastic, and so is Marisa Tomei (2015's "Love the Coopers") in her brief appearance as Aunt May. Also mightily impressing is Chadwick Boseman (2016's "Gods of Egypt") as Prince T'Challa, the grieving, embittered son of the ill-fated King T'Chaka. Boseman charismatically embodies this role with hints that much, much more is yet to come with him. If any subplot suffers as a result of so much going on, it is T'Challa's evolution into Black Panther (Chadwick Boseman). Without warning or explanation, he pops up in costume, able to claw his way down buildings and jump from one moving vehicle to the next as if he's been doing it forever. A couple of other nits to pick: the lack of a strong antagonist in recent Marvel films continues with this films Helmut Zemo. Daniel Bruhl's Zemo (no longer a Baron here) joins the increasingly crowded ranks of underwhelming villains played by fine actors. Marvel movies just don't seem that interested in antagonists other than Loki, putting the emphasis on their heroes' conflicts with each other instead. While Zemo's motive is very human and compelling, his actual scheme doesn't hold up under scrutiny and relies on a few too many coincidences. Also, the way Steve Rogers finds out about the fate of his former love Sharon Carter, comes across as perfunctory.

For a film with a daunting amount of ground to cover, "Captain America: Civil War" never feels overstuffed. Exhibiting command, focus, a sprite rhythm, and more on its mind than the next obligatory fight or explosion, the Russos ensure the picture never lags throughout its 147-minute running time. The inaugural chapter in Phase Three of the Marvel Cinematic Universe, "Captain America: Civil War" has been made with a clear-cut vision and a reverence for its broadening mythology. As long as talented, passionate filmmakers continue to be brought aboard to take these stories and characters in fresh directions, there is no reason to expect this massive franchise will grow stale or lose its vitality anytime soon. It may not quite land in the top tier of superhero movies but it comes a lot closer to hitting that mark than most of the other efforts of the last few years have done because it is the rare film of its type that feels like an actual movie and not just an excuse to sell toys and T-shirts. This is the best “Captain America” film to date and the best “Avengers” film to date. “Civil War” doesn’t bring anything significantly different to the MCU, but it doesn’t have to. Instead of radically altering narrative directions, it maintains the ongoing evolution of these characters, adding to the engaging soap opera atmosphere with new challenges, darker reflections, stranger characters, and enough dramatic heft to feed additional sequels and spin-offs, adding more width to this widescreen world.

CAPTAIN AMERICA CIVIL WAR © 2016 Marvel Entertainment
All Rights Reserved

Review © 2016 Alternate Reality, Inc.



"In an era where we’re obsessed with dark and brooding superheroes, director Joe Johnston’s Captain America is a breath of fresh air." (JR)

"Given how saturated that niche market has become over the past 5-years, it’s quite an achievement on Black’s part that “Iron Man 3” feels so fresh and natural" (JR)

"Big, loud, ridiculous and eye-popping, writer-director Joss Whedon's film is an empty-calorie summertime treat that delivers on all that it promises" (JR)